Best Roof Shingles: Top 10
Brands for Your Home in 2025
FINANCE YOUR HOME IMPROVEMENT PROJECT TODAY
0% Financing on
Roof Replacements
With nearly four decades serving homeowners under our belt, we’ve built relationships with trusted lenders who specialize in roofing projects. We can connect you with financing professionals ready to help fund your roof replacement project.
When you work with County Roofing, you get only the best. As little as 0% interest on approval for 5 years, easy pay, and the best craftsmanship in the industry.
Choosing the right roof shingles is one of the most important decisions you’ll make as a homeowner.
Your roof protects everything inside your home, impacts your curb appeal, and represents a significant financial investment.
But with so many brands and products on the market, how do you know which shingles are actually worth your money?
Roof shingles come in a wide range of materials, styles, and colors, allowing you to select options that not only provide durability and protection but also enhance your home’s aesthetic by complementing its overall style and visual appeal.
In this guide, we’ll break down the top 10 roof shingle brands available today, helping you understand what sets each apart and which might be the best fit for your home.
Types of Roof Shingles
When it comes to selecting the best roof shingles for your home, understanding the different types available is crucial.
Asphalt shingles
Asphalt shingles are by far the most common roofing material in the United States, prized for their affordability, ease of installation, and wide variety of colors and styles.
These shingles are a solid choice for most residential roofing projects, offering reliable durability and a classic look that suits many home designs.
For homeowners seeking enhanced performance or a distinctive appearance, there are several other roofing options to consider.
Architectural / Laminate shingles
Architectural shingles, also known as laminate shingles, provide superior durability and a dimensional look that mimics high-end materials.
Metal shingles
Metal shingles are another excellent option, known for their ability to withstand strong winds, resist severe weather, and offer impressive energy efficiency.
Slate roofing
Slate roofing delivers timeless beauty and exceptional longevity, while clay tiles are valued for their natural material composition and resistance to high temperatures.
Composite shingles
Composite shingles combine the best features of various materials, offering durability, weather resistance, and a range of design choices.
Each type of shingle brings its own set of benefits, from energy efficiency and weather resistance to superior durability and curb appeal.
By understanding the unique characteristics of each roofing material, you can make an informed decision that enhances your home’s protection and style for years to come.
The Benefits of Choosing the Right Roof Shingles
Roof shingles offer a host of advantages that make them a top choice for homeowners across the country.
One of the primary benefits is their ability to protect your home from rain, wind, sun, and snow, ensuring your property stays safe and dry year-round.
Many modern shingles, especially asphalt shingles, are designed for easy installation and low maintenance, making them a practical and cost-effective solution for residential roofing.
Another significant advantage is energy efficiency. Certain types of roof shingles, such as solar shingles, can actually generate electricity for your home, helping to lower your energy bills and reduce your carbon footprint.
Additionally, many shingles are now made from recycled materials, which not only minimizes environmental impact but also supports sustainability efforts within the roofing industry.
Curb appeal is another key benefit—roof shingles come in a wide array of colors, textures, and styles, allowing you to enhance your home’s appearance and potentially increase its value.
With the right roofing material, you can enjoy a durable, attractive, and environmentally friendly roof that stands the test of time.
What Makes a Shingle Brand Stand Out
When evaluating the best roof shingle brands, we considered several critical factors:
Durability and longevity – How well shingles hold up over decades of weather exposure, from summer heat to winter storms.
Wind and impact resistance – Performance ratings that indicate how shingles handle severe weather conditions, including extreme weather events such as high winds, hail, and heavy rain.
Warranty coverage – Both material warranties and the manufacturer’s willingness to stand behind their products.
Design options – Color choices and architectural styles that complement different home designs, including luxury shingles for homeowners seeking high-end appearance, enhanced durability, and the look of premium materials like slate or clay tiles.
Market reputation – Track record with contractors and homeowners based on real-world performance.
Value proposition – The balance between cost and quality, ensuring homeowners get what they pay for.
THE BEST WARRANTIES IN THE INDUSTRY- ONLY 2% OF ROOFING COMPANIES CAN OFFER
25-Year Labor, 50-Year Material Warranty
We’ve met the toughest requirements in the residential roofing industry- and we use only the best materials.
That’s why we stand behind our work with the best warranties in the industry- warranties only 2% of the roofing industry can offer.
Your house deserves the best roofing warranty on the market. Give us a call today and get a brand new roof with a 25-year labor, 50-year material warranty from the best roofing contractor throughout Long Island and New York.
10 Best Roofing Shingle Brands: Our Top Picks for 2025
The brands on our list represent the most trusted names in roofing, each with proven track records of protecting homes across North America.
While we’ve ranked them, the truth is that several of these brands compete head-to-head in quality—with GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning consistently leading the pack.
1. GAF
GAF holds the position as North America’s largest roofing manufacturer, and for good reason. The company has been producing roofing materials since 1886, giving them over 130 years of experience perfecting their products.
GAF’s Timberline HDZ shingles are the best-selling architectural shingles in North America. These shingles feature LayerLock technology that creates exceptional wind resistance—so effective that GAF offers an unlimited wind speed warranty for the first 15 years when installed with required accessories.
GAF also manufactures three tab shingles (also known as tab shingles), which are a more basic and affordable option compared to architectural shingles. Three tab shingles feature a simple, flat design with evenly cut tabs, making them a cost-effective choice for homeowners seeking reliable protection at a lower price point.
Why GAF stands out:
Industry-leading warranties including lifetime limited warranties with enhanced coverage options
Timberline product line with LayerLock technology for superior wind resistance
Widest availability through roofing supply distributors nationwide
Comprehensive contractor certification programs ensuring quality installation
25-year algae protection warranty—significantly longer than most competitors
Extensive color and style options across all price points
GAF invests heavily in innovation and contractor training. Their Master Elite certification program identifies the top contractors in the industry, giving homeowners confidence when selecting an installer.
2. CertainTeed
CertainTeed has built its reputation on exceptional quality since 1904. Based in Pennsylvania, this manufacturer focuses on premium products with some of the most luxurious shingle lines available.
The Landmark series represents CertainTeed’s best-selling architectural shingles, known for superior multi-layer construction and algae resistance. But CertainTeed truly shines in their designer lines—Presidential Shake, Highland Slate, and Grand Manor offer the appearance of premium materials like wood shake and slate at a fraction of the cost.
Why CertainTeed excels:
Exceptional durability with lifetime limited warranties
Premium designer shingles that replicate high-end materials
SureStart protection providing 100% coverage for first 10 years
StreakFighter technology protecting against algae discoloration
Wide variety of architectural styles from classic to luxury
Strong reputation among contractors for consistent quality
CertainTeed shingles typically command premium pricing, but homeowners who prioritize longevity and appearance find the investment worthwhile. The brand is particularly popular for historic homes and high-end properties where aesthetic quality matters most.
3. Owens Corning
Owens Corning brings name recognition beyond roofing thanks to their familiar Pink Panther mascot and presence in retail stores like Home Depot and Lowe’s.
But their market success reflects genuine product quality, not just marketing. Owens Corning manufactures a wide range of asphalt shingle types—including 3-tab, dimensional, and luxury shingles—offering options to suit different homeowner needs and preferences.
The Duration series shingles feature SureNail technology—a reinforced fabric strip that creates up to 2.5 times better nail pull-through resistance. This innovation directly improves wind resistance and long-term performance.
Why Owens Corning delivers:
SureNail technology for enhanced wind resistance and durability
TruDefinition Duration line offering bold, vibrant color options
Excellent balance of quality and affordability in mid-range market
Strong energy efficiency options with Duration Cool shingles
Comprehensive warranty coverage with TRU PROtection
Retail availability making shingles accessible to DIY-oriented homeowners
Owens Corning positions itself as the quality choice for homeowners seeking reliable performance without ultra-premium pricing. Their shingles consistently score well in consumer testing and contractor surveys.
4. Malarkey Roofing Products
Malarkey stands out for innovation and environmental consciousness. This Portland-based manufacturer uses NEX Polymer Modified Asphalt—a rubberized material that enhances flexibility, impact resistance, and overall durability.
While Malarkey doesn’t have the market share of the top three, contractors who use their products often become loyal advocates. The Windsor and Legacy lines offer exceptional performance with Class 4 impact ratings. These shingles are especially recommended for hail prone areas due to their high impact resistance ratings, making them ideal for regions frequently affected by hailstorms.
Why Malarkey impresses:
NEX Polymer Modified Asphalt for enhanced durability and flexibility
Zone 4 hail impact resistance on premium lines
Exceptional warranty options including 50-year non-prorated coverage
Smog-reducing granules that clean air pollution
Sustainable manufacturing using recycled materials
Larger nailing zones for easier, more secure installation
Malarkey represents the premium end of the market. Homeowners willing to invest in top-tier shingles for maximum longevity and performance should seriously consider Malarkey products.
5. Atlas Roofing
Atlas Roofing delivers excellent value—high-quality shingles at competitive prices. The Pinnacle Pristine series consistently scores near the top in consumer testing, offering performance comparable to more expensive brands.
Atlas differentiates itself with HP42 Technology that creates larger shingles for better coverage and material savings. Their Scotchgard Protector helps resist mold, prevent algae growth, and reduce staining.
Why Atlas offers value:
Excellent quality-to-price ratio across product lines
HP42 Technology for enhanced coverage and efficiency
Scotchgard Protector to resist mold, provide algae resistance, and maintain a cleaner appearance
StormMaster series with enhanced wind and impact resistance
Class 4 impact-resistant options available
Strong warranties comparable to premium brands
For homeowners seeking quality shingles without premium pricing, Atlas provides compelling options. Many contractors consider Atlas the best value in the industry.
6. IKO
IKO manufactures in Canada and the United States, bringing cold-weather expertise to their product development. The Nordic and Dynasty lines feature ArmourZone technology for enhanced hail resistance. The wider nailing surface and ArmourZone strip also simplify the installation process for roofing contractors, making material installation more efficient and helping ensure proper attachment for long-term durability.
IKO positions itself in the affordable-to-mid-range market, offering good quality at accessible prices. The Cambridge architectural shingles represent their best-selling product.
Why IKO competes effectively:
ArmourZone technology for superior impact resistance
Dynasty shingles with Class 4 hail rating
Wider nailing surface for improved wind resistance and easier installation process
Affordable pricing making quality shingles accessible
Crowne Slate designer line mimicking natural slate appearance
Good availability through roofing distributors
IKO makes sense for budget-conscious homeowners who still want reliable performance. While not at the premium tier, IKO shingles provide solid protection at reasonable costs.
7. TAMKO
TAMKO has manufactured shingles since 1944, focusing primarily on affordable options for residential construction. The Heritage series represents their most popular architectural shingle line.
TAMKO stands out for color innovation, offering unique tones through their America’s Natural Colors collection. The Titan XT shingles provide exceptional wind resistance up to 160 mph.
Why TAMKO appeals to builders:
Competitive pricing for budget-conscious projects
Heritage series offering good quality at lower costs
Titan XT with extreme wind resistance ratings
Unique color options highlighting American landscapes
Strong presence in new construction market
All products are fire resistant, achieving a Class A fire rating
TAMKO works best for homeowners prioritizing affordability or those planning to sell within a few years. The brand delivers functional protection at accessible price points.
8. BP (PABCO)
BP (formerly PABCO) is a smaller but growing manufacturer offering competitive products. The Vanguard series scored well in independent testing for weight and durability.
While less widely known than industry giants, BP provides solid options for homeowners seeking alternatives to major brands. Their distribution is more regional but expanding.
Why BP deserves consideration:
Strong performance in independent product testing
Competitive pricing in mid-range market
Good weight-per-shingle ratios indicating quality construction
Growing availability through regional distributors
Solid warranty coverage on main product lines
Focus on consistent manufacturing quality
BP makes sense when available in your region and when you’re working with a contractor familiar with their products.
Most roofing contractors are experienced in installing BP shingles, ensuring proper installation and performance. Quality is comparable to better-known mid-tier brands.
9. Brava Roof Tile
Brava takes a different approach—composite tiles that replicate the appearance of slate, shake, and barrel tiles.
These aren’t traditional asphalt shingles but warrant inclusion for homeowners seeking distinctive aesthetics. Brava’s composite tiles offer a unique alternative to other materials such as natural slate, clay, or concrete.
Brava’s composite materials offer Class 4 impact resistance, Class A fire rating, and 50-year warranties. The products suit Mediterranean, Spanish, and luxury home designs.
Why Brava offers unique value:
Composite construction replicating premium tile materials
Significantly lighter than natural slate or concrete tiles
Class 4 impact resistance and Class A fire rating
50-year limited warranty coverage
Beautiful appearance for distinctive architectural styles
No maintenance requirements of natural materials
Brava works for homeowners wanting tile aesthetics without the weight, cost, or maintenance of traditional tile roofing. These represent premium pricing but deliver exceptional visual impact.
10. Davinci Roofscapes
Davinci produces premium synthetic roofing products replicating slate and shake. Like Brava, these aren’t asphalt shingles but composite alternatives offering distinct advantages.
Davinci’s multi-width slate products create remarkably authentic appearances, capturing the Old World charm and elegance of traditional European slate roofs. The materials resist impact, fire, and weather while weighing far less than natural alternatives.
Why Davinci rounds out the top 10:
Exceptional realism mimicking natural slate and shake
Class 4 impact resistance on all products
50-year limited warranty with fade and material guarantees
Significantly lighter than natural slate reducing structural requirements
No maintenance needs or moss growth concerns
Premium aesthetics for luxury and historic homes
Davinci suits homeowners with premium budgets seeking the slate or shake appearance without natural material drawbacks. These represent the high end of the market but deliver unmatched visual appeal.
Professional Installation Makes All the Difference
Here’s the truth about even the best roof shingles: they’re worthless if not installed properly by certified professionals.
The highest-quality GAF, CertainTeed, or Owens Corning shingles won’t perform as designed without correct installation. Proper technique affects everything—wind resistance, water protection, longevity, and warranty validity.
Why professional installation matters:
Manufacturer certifications ensure installers understand specific product requirements.
Each brand has unique specifications for nailing patterns, adhesive activation, ventilation integration, and accessory placement. Shortcuts or improper techniques void warranties and compromise performance.
Quality installation includes:
Proper roof deck preparation
Correct underlayment selection and placement
Strategic ice and water shield application in vulnerable areas
Proper flashing around chimneys and dormers
Adequate ventilation for temperature and moisture control
And correct fastening techniques for wind resistance
Assessing the roof structure is also essential to ensure it can support the chosen roofing materials, especially if you are considering heavier options like steel shingles or slate.
The difference between good and poor installation often doesn’t appear immediately. Problems manifest years later when seals fail, fasteners pull through, or water infiltrates improperly protected areas.
County Roofing Systems: Long Island and New York’s Go-To Roofing Experts
25-Year Labor, 50-Year Material Warranties Only 2% of Roofing Contractors Can Offer
County Roofing Systems stands alone as the only roofing company in Long Island and New York able to offer 25-year labor warranties combined with 50-year material warranties from top manufacturers.
This distinction matters enormously. Most contractors offer material warranties only—meaning if your shingles fail, the manufacturer replaces them, but you pay for installation. If workmanship causes problems, you’re on your own after a few years.
County Roofing Systems’ 25-year labor warranty means we stand behind our installation work for decades, not just months. This comprehensive protection comes from our factory certifications with GAF, CertainTeed, Owens Corning, and other premium manufacturers.
We’ve earned the highest contractor certifications available:
GAF Master Elite Contractor
CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster
Owens Corning Platinum Preferred Contractor
These aren’t marketing titles—they’re earned through rigorous training, proven track records, and commitment to manufacturer standards. Only 2% of roofing companies nationwide achieve these elite certifications.
What this means for you: When County Roofing Systems installs your roof using premium shingles from brands like GAF, CertainTeed, or Owens Corning, you receive both the manufacturer’s 50-year material warranty and our 25-year labor warranty. This combination provides unmatched protection and peace of mind.
We’ve protected Long Island homes for more than 35 years using the best materials and installation techniques in the industry. Our certified installers follow manufacturer specifications precisely, ensuring your roof performs exactly as designed for decades.
Don’t trust your home’s protection to the cheapest bid or an uncertified contractor. The best shingles deserve the best installation—and that’s exactly what County Roofing Systems delivers.
Ready to install a new roof with the best shingles and the best installation warranties available?
Call County Roofing Systems today for a free inspection and estimate. Let us show you exactly how premium shingles and expert installation protect your home for decades to come.
Or complete the form below to schedule your consultation:
0% financing
No income check
Up to 15 years
Monthly payments as low as $149
Call or Contact Us Today for a FREE roofing estimate:
