UPDATED FOR 2025
CertainTeed Carriage House Shingles Review: Victorian Elegance Meets Modern Durability
Are Carriage House shingles for you? Learn more in this comprehensive CertainTeed Carriage House shingle review.
Key Takeaways:
- Carriage House recreates Victorian-era scalloped roofing with distinctive three-dimensional profile
- 425 pounds per square makes these CertainTeed’s heaviest shingles for maximum durability
- 130 mph wind resistance when certified-installed protects against nor’easters and tropical storms
- Class A fire rating provides highest fire protection available
- Perfect for period homes especially Victorian, Queen Anne, and Gothic Revival architecture
Want a roof that matches your Victorian home’s character?
Carriage House delivers authentic period appearance.
These luxury shingles from CertainTeed capture the scalloped, layered appearance found on turn-of-the-century homes. You get historical authenticity without the maintenance nightmares, structural challenges, or costs of original roofing materials.
We’ve installed Carriage House roofs across Long Island for over 35 years. We’ve seen how they perform on everything from waterfront Victorian estates to inland cottage-style homes.
Below, we’ll break down what makes Carriage House unique and whether these premium shingles are right for your home.
What Makes Carriage House Different
Carriage House occupies special place in CertainTeed’s luxury lineup.
Most premium shingles aim to replicate standard slate or wood shake appearances. Carriage House specifically recreates the distinctive scalloped pattern found on period architecture.
This makes them particularly well-suited for Victorian, Queen Anne, Gothic Revival, and other historical styles where authenticity matters.
Scalloped Design Creates Authentic Appeal
The design features multiple layers creating deep shadow lines.
Prominent three-dimensional profile becomes especially striking when viewed from street level. The scalloped edge gives each shingle unique appearance. The irregular pattern creates visual interest while maintaining clean lines expected from modern roofing products.
At approximately 425 pounds per square, Carriage House ranks among CertainTeed’s heaviest shingles. This substantial weight contributes to exceptional durability, superior wind resistance, enhanced sound dampening, and improved insulation properties.
Integration With Complete Roofing System
These shingles integrate seamlessly with CertainTeed’s complete Integrity Roof System.
Every component from underlayment to ventilation is designed to work together for optimal performance. This system approach ensures compatibility across all elements while maximizing warranty coverage.
Let’s discuss the historical context that makes Carriage House special.
FINANCE YOUR HOME IMPROVEMENT PROJECT TODAY
0% Financing, Quick and Easy Approval
With nearly four decades serving homeowners under our belt, we know what’s needed to make your roofing project a success.
When you work with County Roofing, you get only the best. As little as 0% interest on approval for 5 years, quick approval, easy pay, and all backed by the best guarantees in the industry.
Design Heritage That Honors Architecture
Understanding Carriage House requires appreciating historical roofing styles it emulates.
Victorian-era homes often featured elaborate roofing with scalloped slate tiles or shaped wood shingles. These added decorative elements to functional roofs. They were labor-intensive to install and maintain. They were expensive. Sometimes they were structurally problematic due to weight.
Modern Solution to Period Roofing
Carriage House captures that authentic period appearance while solving all practical problems.
The scalloped design creates ornate, detailed look that complements historic architecture. But it doesn’t require specialized installation skills or create maintenance nightmares.
The color palette reflects earthy, natural tones common in period roofing. Options include Georgetown Gray, Cobblestone Gray, Aged Cedar, and others that work beautifully with Victorian color schemes while remaining versatile enough for updated exteriors.
Max Def color technology ensures these hues maintain depth and vibrancy for decades. They resist fading that can make older roofs look tired and worn.
Where Carriage House Shines Brightest
The dimensional quality makes Carriage House particularly effective on homes with complex rooflines.
Turrets, dormers, multiple roof planes, and varied pitches all showcase the scalloped edge and layered construction. You see visual interest from every angle rather than just specific viewpoints.
Even on simpler roof designs, Carriage House adds architectural distinction that elevates the home’s overall appearance. The unique profile ensures your roof becomes design feature rather than simply functional overhead protection.
Now let’s talk about performance in our challenging climate.
How Carriage House Performs in Long Island Weather
Visual appeal matters, but Long Island weather demands genuine performance.
Wind Resistance That Protects Your Investment
Standard installation withstands 110 mph winds.
When we install Carriage House following complete CertainTeed specifications, that rating increases to 130 mph with appropriate warranty coverage. We’re a CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster, which means we meet those specifications exactly.
We’ve seen Carriage House roofs withstand significant nor’easters and tropical storm remnants without damage. The weight and secure attachment method keep these shingles firmly in place even during severe wind events.
Impact Resistance From Heavyweight Construction
Multi-layered construction and substantial thickness resist damage.
While Carriage House doesn’t carry Class 4 impact rating, the heavyweight design handles hail, wind-blown debris, and falling branches better than standard shingles. This durability proves valuable during storms when projectiles and heavy precipitation test your roof’s resilience.
Fire Protection at Highest Standard
Class A rating means these shingles withstand extended flame exposure without igniting.
This provides crucial protection for your family and property. It often translates to lower homeowners insurance premiums compared to homes with lesser fire-rated materials.
Algae Resistance Built In
StreakFighter technology incorporates copper granules throughout the shingles.
These inhibit algae growth that commonly creates dark streaks on roofs in humid climates. Long Island’s coastal environment encourages algae development, making this protection particularly valuable for maintaining your home’s appearance.
Thermal Performance Benefits
Carriage House’s substantial thickness provides better insulation than thinner shingles.
This helps regulate attic temperatures. It’s especially noticeable during summer months when intense sun exposure can create significant attic heat buildup with standard shingles.
Let’s discuss real-world durability in coastal conditions.
THE BEST GUARANTEE IN THE INDUSTRY
50-Year Material, 25-Year Labor Guarantee
We’ve met the toughest requirements in the residential roofing industry- and we use only the best materials.
That’s why we stand behind our work with the best guarantee in the industry– including warranties only 2% of roofing companies can offer.
Your house deserves the best roofing warranty on the market. Give us a call today and get a brand new roof with a 50-year material, 25-year labor warranty from the best roofing contractor in Long Island and New York.
Real-World Performance in Coastal Environment
Long Island’s location brings unique challenges.
Salt air, high humidity, temperature extremes, winter storms, and summer heat all test roofing materials. Carriage House has proven its ability to handle these conditions over many years.
Salt Air Doesn’t Cause Problems
Coastal exposure hasn’t shown adverse effects on Carriage House installations.
Granule adhesion remains strong. Asphalt composition resists degradation from coastal exposure. We’ve installed these shingles on homes ranging from inland locations to waterfront properties, with consistently excellent performance across all environments.
Humidity Gets Handled
Algae resistance technology genuinely works.
Homes in heavily shaded areas or near significant tree cover may eventually develop some algae growth. But onset is delayed and severity reduced compared to standard shingles.
Winter Freeze-Thaw Cycles
Flexible asphalt composition maintains integrity through temperature swings.
Granule coating stays firmly attached rather than loosening and washing away. Carriage House handles the freeze-thaw cycles that can crack and damage lesser products.
Summer Heat Stress
Ceramic-coated granules protect against UV damage.
Premium asphalt formulation resists thermal degradation. Heat stress that can cause softening, scuffing, or premature aging in lower-quality shingles doesn’t significantly affect Carriage House.
Installation requirements matter for these luxury shingles.
Why Professional Installation Is Critical
Carriage House isn’t basic product.
These luxury shingles require professional expertise to ensure both proper performance and the aesthetic quality you’re investing in.
Weight Verification First
425 pounds per square requires verifying your roof structure can support the load.
Modern construction typically handles this without issue. Older homes or those with previous structural concerns may need reinforcement. This assessment happens during our initial inspection, with recommendations provided if strengthening is necessary.
Following System Specifications
Proper installation follows CertainTeed’s detailed Integrity Roof System specifications.
Appropriate underlayment layers for enhanced protection. Precise starter strip positioning. Correct nailing patterns accounting for shingle weight and profile. Careful attention to flashing details around all roof penetrations, valleys, and transitions.
Special Attention to Scalloped Edge
The scalloped edge requires particular care during installation.
Each shingle needs positioning that creates authentic period look while ensuring adequate overlap and secure attachment. This attention to detail takes time but produces superior results you expect from luxury shingles.
Why Certification Matters
As CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster, we’ve proven our expertise through comprehensive testing.
We’ve met strict quality standards. We maintain customer satisfaction requirements. This certification ensures your Carriage House roof qualifies for CertainTeed’s best warranty coverage.
Our 25-year labor warranty backs up this quality commitment. We’re here for your roof for decades, not just during installation.
Contact us below to get started transforming your old roof today.
Fill out the form below or give us a call today at (888) 366-6619:
Comprehensive Warranty Coverage
Carriage House comes with warranty protection that demonstrates CertainTeed’s confidence.
Lifetime limited warranty covers manufacturing defects. SureStart PLUS provides 100 percent material and labor coverage during first 10 years with no depreciation.
What County Roofing Systems Adds
When we install your Carriage House roof, you receive:
50 years of coverage against manufacturing defects
25 years of labor warranty from us
Enhanced wind warranty up to 130 mph when properly installed
15-year StreakFighter algae resistance warranty
This coverage exceeds standard industry warranties. It protects your investment for decades. The 25-year labor warranty is particularly significant since most contractors offer far shorter coverage periods.
This extended warranty reflects our confidence that your roof will perform reliably throughout its lifespan.
Now let’s discuss investment and value.
Understanding the Investment
Carriage House represents premium investment in your home.
Expect to pay 50 to 80 percent above mid-range options for comparable roof area. Pricing reflects both superior materials and specialized installation expertise required.
Value Beyond Initial Cost
Exceptional durability translates to longer lifespan with fewer repairs.
Heavy construction and quality materials withstand weather extremes better than standard products. This reduces likelihood of storm damage requiring expensive fixes.
Enhanced curb appeal provides immediate visual impact that can increase home value. Real estate professionals consistently note that homes with distinctive, well-maintained roofs command premium prices and attract more buyer interest.
Lower maintenance requirements save ongoing time and money. Unlike natural slate or wood shakes requiring regular treatment and frequent repairs, Carriage House needs minimal maintenance beyond periodic inspections and gutter cleaning.
Energy efficiency benefits from improved insulation properties contribute to reduced heating and cooling costs over roof’s lifetime.
Historical Authenticity Matters
For period homes where appropriate roofing is crucial to architectural integrity, Carriage House provides that authenticity without drawbacks of original materials.
This value is hard to quantify but matters significantly for homeowners who appreciate historical accuracy.
Financing Available
We offer financing options for qualified customers.
This spreads investment over time rather than requiring everything upfront. You get the roof you want without immediate budget strain.
Who benefits most from Carriage House?
Ideal Applications for Carriage House
Carriage House excels in specific situations.
Perfect Candidates
Victorian and period architecture where historical accuracy matters. Carriage House delivers authentic period appearance that complements architectural details these homes feature.
Complex rooflines with multiple planes, turrets, dormers, and varied pitches that showcase dimensional quality and distinctive scalloped edge from multiple viewpoints.
Upscale neighborhoods where home appearance significantly affects property values and where distinctive roofing helps homes stand out positively.
Coastal locations where salt air, humidity, and storm exposure demand superior durability combined with aesthetic appeal.
Homes with attention to architectural detail where owners appreciate craftsmanship and want every element contributing to character.
When to Consider Alternatives
Budget limitations require focusing on most cost-effective solution. Your home has simple contemporary architecture where period aesthetic doesn’t fit.
You plan to sell soon and won’t recoup investment premium. Your roof structure needs expensive reinforcement to support weight. You prefer clean, modern lines rather than ornate period styling.
Let’s wrap this up with clear guidance.
Get Expert Guidance on Your Decision
Considering Carriage House for your home?
Schedule consultation to discuss your specific situation. We’ll evaluate your roof structure, review your aesthetic goals, show you color samples, and provide detailed installation estimate.
We can often direct you to nearby homes with Carriage House roofs. Seeing these distinctive shingles in person helps you understand whether they’re right fit for your home.
Why Work With Certified Installers
Our CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster certification and decades of experience with luxury roofing products provide expertise you need.
We’ll provide honest advice about whether Carriage House suits your specific situation or if another option might serve you better.
Call County Roofing Systems today. With over 35 years serving Long Island, we’ll guide you through every aspect of the decision and installation process.
Carriage House delivers authentic period elegance combined with modern roofing technology that protects your home for decades. For Victorian homes and other period architecture, these shingles provide unmatched aesthetic authenticity along with performance that meets today’s demanding standards.
Fast & Easy Financing with County Roofing
Financing your commercial roofing project has never been easier.
With County Roofing, you can get fast approvals with as low as 0% financing on new roofing projects for up to 15 years, with payments as low as $149:
First Approvals
0% financing
No income check
Up to 15 years
Monthly payments as low as $149
Fill out the form below or give us a call at (888) 366-6619 today to get started:
Call or contact us today
for your free comprehensive roofing estimate.
Call Us Today: (888) 366-6619
Frequently Asked Questions
What makes Carriage House different from other luxury shingles?
Carriage House specifically replicates Victorian-era scalloped roofing patterns while other luxury shingles mimic standard slate or wood shake. The distinctive scalloped edge and period-authentic appearance makes it ideal for historical architecture. At 425 pounds per square, it’s CertainTeed’s heaviest shingle, providing maximum durability.
How long do Carriage House shingles last?
Carriage House typically lasts 30 to 40 years with proper installation and maintenance. The heavyweight construction and quality materials resist weather damage better than standard shingles. CertainTeed backs them with lifetime limited warranty, with first 50 years covered against manufacturing defects.
Can Carriage House be used on non-Victorian homes?
Yes, though the period aesthetic works best on homes with architectural character. Cottage-style, craftsman, and some traditional homes benefit from Carriage House’s distinctive appearance. However, ultra-modern contemporary homes might be better served by other luxury options that match their design language.
Does Carriage House qualify for insurance discounts?
The Class A fire rating may qualify for insurance discounts. Wind resistance rating can reduce premiums in coastal areas. Contact your insurance provider to discuss specific discounts available. Documentation of professional installation by certified contractor helps maximize potential savings.
What maintenance does Carriage House require?
Keep gutters clear of debris. Trim overhanging branches to prevent damage. Schedule annual inspections to catch minor issues early. The algae-resistant technology reduces need for roof cleaning. Avoid walking on roof unnecessarily to prevent granule loss. Essentially minimal maintenance beyond these basic steps.
Can my roof support Carriage House's weight?
Most residential structures built in last 50 years can support Carriage House without issue. Older Victorian-era homes were often built with substantial framing to support heavy original slate or tile roofing. We assess your specific structure during initial inspection and provide recommendations if reinforcement is needed.
