UPDATED FOR 2025
GAF Royal Sovereign vs. Owens Corning Supreme: Are Three-Tab Shingles Still Worth Installing?
Compare GAF Royal Sovereign and Owens Corning Supreme three-tab shingles for Long Island homes. Learn when three-tab makes sense, cost savings, warranty concerns, and architectural alternatives.
Key Takeaways:
- Three-tab shingles save $3,000-4,000 on typical Long Island roof replacement compared to architectural shingles from leading manufacturers in the roofing industry
- Both GAF Royal Sovereign and Owens Corning Supreme offer limited warranties typically 25-30 years versus limited lifetime coverage on architectural products from both GAF and Owens Corning
- Wind resistance is significantly lower with three-tab shingles rated at 60-70 MPH versus 110-130 MPH for architectural products in the GAF vs Owens Corning comparison
- Flat appearance lacks dimensional aesthetics that architectural shingles provide potentially impacting curb appeal and resale value
- Three-tab makes sense for rental properties, temporary solutions, or extreme budget constraints but rarely represents the best long-term value for owner-occupied homes
- Owens Corning and GAF both offer superior architectural alternatives that County Roofing Systems as your roofing contractor recommends for most Long Island homes and roofing projects
- What Owens Corning offers and what GAF shingles offer in their architectural lines far exceeds three-tab performance making the premium worthwhile
Three-tab shingles dominated residential roofing for decades before architectural shingles took over.
Today, three-tab products like GAF Royal Sovereign and Owens Corning Supreme represent roughly 5-10% of new residential installations nationwide—down from 70-80% in the 1990s.
The shift happened for good reasons.
Architectural shingles from both GAF and Owens Corning offer better wind resistance, longer warranties, superior aesthetics, and better long-term value despite higher upfront costs. Both GAF shingles and Owens Corning shingles deliver proven performance that has made them industry leaders.
But three-tab roofing materials haven’t disappeared entirely. They still make sense for specific situations—rental properties, budget-constrained projects, garages and outbuildings, or short-term ownership before planned replacement.
For a typical Long Island home, three-tab shingles save $3,000-4,000 compared to architectural products from GAF and Owens Corning.
That’s real money for homeowners facing tight budgets.
The question is whether that savings justifies the compromises you’re accepting.
What Are Three-Tab Shingles?
Three-tab shingles represent the original asphalt shingle design that dominated residential roofing from the 1950s through 1990s.
The name comes from the shingle’s construction—three distinct tabs separated by cutouts creating a uniform, repetitive pattern across your roof.
Each shingle measures roughly 12 inches by 36 inches with the three 12-inch tabs visible from street view.
When installed, the cutouts align to create a very flat, linear appearance.
Construction is straightforward. A fiberglass or organic mat base provides structure. Asphalt coating adds waterproofing.
Ceramic granules on the surface protect against UV damage and provide color.
The entire shingle is relatively thin and lightweight compared to architectural products—usually weighing 200-240 pounds per square versus 260-340 pounds for architectural shingles.
That simpler construction translates directly to lower manufacturing costs and lower retail pricing. Three-tab shingles typically cost $25-35 per bundle retail versus $35-50+ for architectural shingles.
For materials covering a 2,000 square foot Long Island roof, that’s roughly $1,500-2,000 savings on shingles alone before considering labor and other materials.
The Trade-Offs
The trade-offs for this cost savings include flat appearance with minimal visual interest, lower wind resistance due to thinner construction and larger cutout areas, shorter warranty periods from most manufacturers, and faster granule loss and weathering compared to thicker architectural products.
FINANCE YOUR HOME IMPROVEMENT PROJECT TODAY
0% Financing, Quick and Easy Approval
With nearly four decades serving homeowners under our belt, we know what’s needed to make your roofing project a success.
When you work with County Roofing, you get only the best. As little as 0% interest on approval for 5 years, quick approval, easy pay, and all backed by the best guarantees in the industry.
GAF Royal Sovereign: Features and Specifications
GAF Royal Sovereign represents GAF’s primary three-tab offering for residential applications. GAF stands for “General Aniline & Film” and is recognized as one of the most reputable and innovative roofing manufacturers in the industry, known for its commitment to quality and technological advancement.
The shingles use fiberglass mat construction for strength and durability. GAF’s proprietary granule coating provides color and UV protection. GAF roofing shingles are widely respected for their range of styles, affordability, and performance, making them a leading choice for homeowners and contractors alike.
The product includes what GAF calls “Advanced Protection Shingle Technology,” which enhances durability, optimizes weight, and improves weather resistance for longer-lasting performance.
Wind resistance is rated at 60 MPH with standard installation using four nails per shingle. This can upgrade to 70 MPH when using six nails per shingle and high-wind installation methods. GAF shingles can withstand winds up to 130 mph on higher-end lines and feature StainGuard technology to prevent algae growth. GAF also provides additional reinforcement with its LayerLock and Dura Grip adhesive for superior strength in extreme conditions, and the StrikeZone nailing area helps reduce installer errors.
Compare this to Timberline HDZ’s 130 MPH rating.
Royal Sovereign offers less than half the wind resistance. However, GAF’s WindProven Limited Wind Warranty offers no wind speed cap for certain installations, providing industry-leading wind warranty protection.
Warranty coverage is limited to 25 years on materials for manufacturing defects. This is significantly shorter than the limited lifetime warranties GAF provides on architectural products like Timberline HDZ. GAF warranties are well-regarded, with most products offering a lifetime limited warranty, though the 3-tab shingles warranty is not as strong as the architectural and luxury shingles warranty.
After 25 years, you have no manufacturer warranty coverage even if the shingles are still in reasonable condition.
Royal Sovereign does not include algae-resistant technology. No copper granules. No algae warranty.
Your roof is completely vulnerable to the black streaking that plagues Long Island roofs in our humid coastal climate.
GAF is particularly popular among contractors for its extensive training and certification programs, and GAF shingles are generally more affordable, making them a great option for budget-conscious homeowners.
Available colors are limited—typically 8-10 basic options including neutrals like Weathered Wood, Pewter Gray, and Charcoal. GAF provides a broad selection of shingles in various styles and colors across its product lines, including designer shingles for a high-end appearance and Timberline shingles in a variety of colors and styles to suit different preferences.
The color selection is adequate for basic applications but far more limited than architectural lines offering 20-40+ colors.
GAF’s Cool Series shingles are also available as an energy-efficient option, featuring heat-reflective properties and ENERGY STAR certification for homeowners seeking to reduce energy costs.
Pricing for Royal Sovereign runs approximately $65-85 per square installed on Long Island. For a typical 2,000 square foot roof (20 squares), total installed cost including tear-off and basic accessories runs $5,500-8,000.
Owens Corning Supreme: Features and Specifications
Owens Corning Supreme shingles compete directly with GAF Royal Sovereign as their standard three-tab product and are part of the Owens Corning roofing shingles product line.
Owens Corning Roofing is a trusted brand known for high-performance shingles and complete roofing systems. Supreme shingles are constructed with premium materials, which contributes to their slightly higher price point and advanced features. The shingles use fiberglass mat construction similar to Royal Sovereign, but Owens Corning’s manufacturing quality and materials science provide good base durability.
Owens Corning stands out by incorporating SureNail® Technology in many of their shingles, which improves wind resistance and makes installation easier. The SureNail strip provides a more straightforward nailing process favored by many roofing contractors. Additionally, the Total Protection Roofing System integrates various components for maximum durability and long-term performance.
The product represents competent three-tab construction from a reputable manufacturer. Owens Corning warranties include a lifetime limited warranty on most shingles, and their architectural shingles warranty offers a lifetime material warranty with a 130 mph wind resistance rating, ensuring long-term protection for homeowners. Platinum Preferred Contractors, the top-tier certification for Owens Corning roofing installers, are eligible to offer enhanced or extended warranties on Owens Corning products.
Nothing innovative, but solid execution of traditional design.
Wind resistance matches Royal Sovereign at 60 MPH with standard four-nail installation, upgrading to 70 MPH with six-nail high-wind installation.
Again, this is less than half the wind resistance of architectural products like Duration (130 MPH).
Warranty coverage provides 30 years on materials—slightly longer than Royal Sovereign’s 25 years but still far shorter than the limited lifetime coverage on Owens Corning’s architectural products.
The warranty is prorated, meaning coverage value decreases over time rather than maintaining full replacement value.
Supreme does not include algae-resistant technology. No StreakGuard protection. No algae warranty.
The shingles will develop black algae streaks in Long Island’s climate just like Royal Sovereign and any other non-protected product.
Color selection is limited to 8-12 basic options including Estate Gray, Driftwood, Desert Tan, and Onyx Black. While the Supreme line is more basic, Owens Corning offers a wide range of colors in their other shingle lines, and their TruDefinition technology enhances color vibrancy and depth, making their architectural shingles visually appealing and enhancing the overall appearance of a home.
Adequate for utilitarian applications but lacking the variety of architectural lines.
Pricing for Supreme runs approximately $60-80 per square installed on Long Island. For a 2,000 square foot roof, total installed cost runs $5,000-7,500—roughly comparable to or slightly less than Royal Sovereign.
THE BEST GUARANTEE IN THE INDUSTRY
50-Year Material, 25-Year Labor Guarantee
We’ve met the toughest requirements in the residential roofing industry- and we use only the best materials.
That’s why we stand behind our work with the best guarantee in the industry– including warranties only 2% of roofing companies can offer.
Your house deserves the best roofing warranty on the market. Give us a call today and get a brand new roof with a 50-year material, 25-year labor warranty from the best roofing contractor in Long Island and New York.
Cost Comparison: Three-Tab vs. Architectural Shingles
Let’s examine the actual dollar differences between three-tab and architectural products for Long Island homes.
Three-tab shingles (Royal Sovereign or Supreme): Material cost approximately $60-85 per square installed. Total cost for 2,000 square foot roof: $5,000-8,000 including tear-off, underlayment, ventilation, and accessories.
Architectural shingles (Timberline HDZ shingles or Duration): Material cost approximately $95-120 per square installed. Total cost for same 2,000 square foot roof: $8,000-12,000 including all materials and labor.
The difference: $3,000-4,000 for a typical Long Island home. That’s significant money for many homeowners, particularly those facing unexpected roof replacement due to storm damage or those already stretching budgets for necessary home repairs.
However, this cost comparison doesn’t tell the complete story.
You’re not simply paying $3,000-4,000 more for architectural shingles. You’re receiving substantially more value.
What the Premium Buys
Limited lifetime warranty versus 25-30 year limited warranty. Your architectural roof is covered for as long as you own your home versus losing manufacturer warranty after 25-30 years with three-tab.
130 MPH wind resistance versus 60-70 MPH. Your architectural roof from GAF’s complete roofing system or Owens Corning’s Total Protection Roofing System can handle Long Island’s coastal storms far more effectively.
Three-tab shingles are vulnerable to wind damage during severe nor’easters or tropical systems.
25 years of algae protection (with products like Timberline HDZ) versus no algae protection. Your architectural roof stays clean while three-tab develops unsightly black streaks within 3-5 years.
This requires expensive cleaning or living with poor appearance.
Enhanced curb appeal and property value. Architectural shingles’ dimensional appearance looks substantially better than three-tab’s flat aesthetic.
This potentially adds $2,000-5,000 to property value in typical Long Island markets.
Longer expected lifespan. Architectural shingles typically last 25-30 years on Long Island versus 15-20 years for three-tab products.
Over a 30-year period, you might need two three-tab roofs versus one architectural roof.
When Three-Tab Shingles Make Sense
Despite the disadvantages, three-tab shingles remain appropriate for specific situations.
Rental Properties
If you own investment properties and need functional roofing at minimum cost, three-tab provides adequate protection at the lowest price point.
You’re not living in the property.
Curb appeal matters less. You can plan for replacement after 15-20 years.
Garages and Outbuildings
For structures where aesthetics don’t matter and matching the main house isn’t necessary, three-tab saves money without meaningful compromises.
A detached garage doesn’t need dimensional shingles or 130 MPH wind resistance.
Short-Term Ownership
If you’re planning to tear down or extensively renovate within 5-10 years, installing three-tab for temporary protection makes economic sense.
You’re not investing in 30-year roofing when the structure won’t exist in that timeframe.
Extreme Budget Constraints
If you absolutely cannot afford architectural shingles even with financing, and you need immediate roof replacement to prevent interior damage, three-tab provides functional protection at rock-bottom pricing.
Heavily Wooded Properties
If your property has exceptional tree shading reducing algae risk, and you’re not concerned about curb appeal, three-tab’s compromises matter less.
Though County Roofing Systems still recommends architectural products even in these situations.
These situations represent maybe 10-15% of Long Island residential roofing projects. For the remaining 85-90% of homeowners, architectural shingles provide substantially better long-term value despite higher upfront costs.
When Three-Tab Shingles Don’t Make Sense
Three-tab shingles are usually poor choices for owner-occupied Long Island homes.
You Plan Long-Term Ownership
If you plan to stay in your home 10+ years, the limited warranty, algae vulnerability, and shorter expected lifespan make three-tab a false economy.
The upfront savings disappear quickly when you face algae cleaning costs, wind damage repairs, or premature replacement.
Your Home Value Exceeds $400,000
At this price point, buyers expect architectural shingles as standard. Three-tab creates unfavorable comparison reducing property value or extending time on market when you eventually sell.
Architectural Shingles Are Neighborhood Standard
Making your home the only one with three-tab creates aesthetic disparity that hurts curb appeal relative to surrounding properties.
High Roof Visibility
If your home’s architectural style showcases the roof prominently—steep pitches, dormers, complex roof lines—three-tab’s flat appearance is particularly unflattering.
Coastal or High-Wind Locations
Three-tab’s 60-70 MPH wind resistance is inadequate for South Shore locations, waterfront properties, or areas with high wind exposure during coastal storms.
You Value Home Appearance
If you take pride in your property and want it to look its best, three-tab’s budget aesthetic won’t satisfy you.
Financing Is Available
If home equity loans, contractor financing, or insurance claim settlements make architectural shingles affordable, the long-term value strongly favors that investment.
County Roofing Systems recommends architectural shingles in all these situations—which covers the vast majority of Long Island homeowner consultations.
We install three-tab when clients insist despite our recommendations, but we’re upfront that it’s rarely the best choice for owner-occupied homes.
Are Three-Tab Shingles Worth Installing in 2025?
The roofing industry’s shift away from three-tab happened for good reasons.
Architectural shingles provide better wind resistance, longer warranties, algae protection, enhanced aesthetics, and superior long-term value.
The upfront premium of $3,000-4,000 is meaningful.
But the additional benefits justify that cost for most homeowners over a 20-30 year ownership period.
The market reflects this reality. Three-tab shingles represented 70-80% of residential installations in the 1990s.
Today they’re 5-10% and continuing to decline.
Most manufacturers have reduced their three-tab product lines or stopped innovating in that category entirely, focusing resources on architectural and premium products instead.
Both GAF and Owens Corning now offer a wide range of premium shingles, including architectural and luxury shingles, as well as impact resistant shingles designed for specific roofing needs. Their designer shingles emulate the look of natural materials like wood and slate, appealing to homeowners seeking luxury aesthetics and distinctive curb appeal. These luxury shingles are part of broader product lines that provide enhanced durability, wind resistance, and upscale design options.
When comparing GAF and Owens Corning’s premium and luxury shingle options, GAF’s luxury shingles have a higher wind resistance rating, while both brands offer designer shingles tailored for specific roofing requirements.
It’s important to consider comparing GAF and Owens Corning when choosing the right shingles for your home; Owens Corning edges ahead in certain areas due to innovative features like SureNail technology, which enhances quality and durability. Both brands also provide energy-efficient roofing solutions. GAF shingles are generally more affordable, while Owens Corning shingles are slightly more expensive due to their advanced features and technology.
For specific situations—rental properties, temporary roofing, extreme budget constraints—three-tab still makes economic sense.
The cost savings are real and the compromises may be acceptable given those circumstances.
But for typical Long Island homeowners buying a roof they’ll live under for 15-25 years, three-tab represents short-term thinking that usually costs more long-term.
The Hidden Costs Add Up
Algae staining within 5 years requiring $800 cleaning. Wind damage during severe storms. Replacement at year 18-20 instead of year 28-30.
Reduced property value when selling.
The $3,000-4,000 upfront savings evaporates quickly.
County Roofing Systems installs three-tab products when appropriate but recommends architectural shingles for 85-90% of consultations.
The performance, protection, and aesthetic advantages justify the premium. And with financing options making the cost difference manageable through monthly payments, more homeowners can access architectural quality without overwhelming upfront expenses.
Fill out the form below or give us a call today at (888) 366-6619:
Financing Options Making Architectural Shingles Accessible
The $3,000-4,000 difference between three-tab and architectural shingles becomes more manageable with financing.
Many homeowners can access home equity loans or home equity lines of credit (HELOCs) at favorable interest rates using their home’s value as collateral.
A $4,000 HELOC at 8% APR over 5 years costs roughly $81 monthly.
That’s potentially less than the cost of professional algae cleaning every 3-4 years that three-tab roofs require.
Contractor financing programs offered by many roofing companies including County Roofing Systems provide structured payment plans.
Typical terms might be 12-24 months same-as-cash or 60-84 months with competitive interest rates.
Breaking a $12,000 architectural roof into 60 monthly payments of $200 makes premium quality accessible to homeowners who couldn’t afford $12,000 upfront.
Insurance claims following storm damage often cover architectural shingles when depreciation and actual cash value calculations account for the damaged roof’s age and type.
Homeowners paying out-of-pocket for the deductible and any upgrades find that upgrading from old three-tab to new architectural might cost just $2,000-3,000 more than replacing with three-tab after insurance contribution.
County Roofing Systems works with homeowners to explore financing options making architectural shingles accessible even when upfront budgets are tight.
We’ve found that when homeowners understand the long-term value and can spread costs over time, most choose architectural products over three-tab.
Get a Free Roofing Estimate from County Roofing Systems
Three-tab shingles like GAF Royal Sovereign and Owens Corning Supreme save $3,000-4,000 compared to architectural alternatives on typical Long Island roofs.
But that upfront savings comes with significant compromises—60-70 MPH wind resistance versus 130 MPH, 25-30 year limited warranties versus limited lifetime coverage, no algae protection in Long Island’s humid climate, flat aesthetic hurting curb appeal, and shorter expected lifespan requiring earlier replacement.
For rental properties, garages, short-term temporary roofing, or extreme budget constraints, three-tab shingles provide functional protection at rock-bottom pricing.
These situations represent roughly 10-15% of Long Island residential roofing projects.
For the remaining 85-90% of owner-occupied homes, architectural shingles provide substantially better long-term value despite higher upfront costs.
The performance advantages, warranty benefits, algae protection, and aesthetic improvements justify the premium—particularly when financing options make the cost difference manageable through monthly payments.
County Roofing Systems has served Long Island for over 35 years. We hold certifications with all major manufacturers (GAF Master Elite, Owens Corning Platinum Preferred, CertainTeed SELECT ShingleMaster) and can install both three-tab and architectural products to manufacturer specifications.
We provide honest guidance about when three-tab makes sense and when it doesn’t. We’ll show you physical samples of both product types, explain the real-world performance differences, and help you understand the complete cost picture including long-term expenses beyond just upfront installation.
We’ll also help you explore financing options that might make architectural shingles accessible even if upfront budget is tight.
Call County Roofing Systems today at (888) 766-6619 for a free roof inspection and consultation. We’ll assess your current roof, explain your options between three-tab and architectural products, and provide the expertise that comes from thousands of installations across Long Island’s diverse neighborhoods and property types.
Your roof protects your home for 20-30 years. Make sure you’re making the choice that provides the best balance of upfront cost, long-term value, and protection for your specific situation.
In 2025, that choice is usually architectural shingles—but we’ll help you determine whether your circumstances are among the exceptions where three-tab makes economic sense.
- First Approvals
- 0% financing
- No income check
- Up to 15 years
- Monthly payments as low as $149
Contact us below for a FREE roofing estimate:
