UPDATED FOR 2025
Does a New Roof Lower Your Homeowners Insurance?
Discover how a new roof lowers your homeowners insurance on Long Island. Including premium reductions, impact-resistant discounts, and documentation tips.
Key Takeaways:
- New roofs typically reduce homeowners insurance premiums by 10-25% annually, saving Long Island homeowners $200-$600+ per year depending on coverage levels and home value.
- Impact-resistant shingles can qualify for additional 15-30% premium discounts beyond standard new roof reductions, with savings varying by insurance carrier and policy terms.
- Roofs older than 15-20 years face substantial insurance penalties including premium surcharges of 25-50%, coverage restrictions limiting reimbursement to actual cash value rather than replacement cost, or outright policy cancellation.
- Many factors influence whether and how much a new roof lowers your homeowners insurance, such as your location, roof type, and individual insurer policies.
- Proper documentation—installation receipts, warranty papers, and contractor certifications—is essential for securing insurance discounts and preventing claim denials when roof damage occurs.
If you’re tired of watching your Long Island homeowners insurance premiums climb year after year, your aging roof might be the culprit—and replacing it could be the solution.
Insurance companies assess roof age and condition carefully when setting rates, and older roofs mean higher premiums, coverage restrictions, or even policy cancellations.
A new roof does more than protect your home from storms and leaks—it can reduce your annual insurance costs by hundreds of dollars while improving coverage options and eliminating surcharges.
Understanding how insurance companies evaluate roofs and what factors trigger premium reductions helps you maximize savings while protecting your most valuable investment.
The Quick Answer: Yes, a New Roof Lowers Your Insurance Costs
A new roof typically reduces your Long Island homeowners insurance premiums by 10-25% annually.
For a home with $2,500 annual insurance premiums, that’s $250-$625 in yearly savings. Over a roof’s 25-30 year lifespan, you’re looking at $6,250-$18,750 in total insurance savings—a significant return that offsets a portion of your replacement investment.
However, insurance premium savings can vary significantly depending on your insurer, location, and other factors.
The exact insurance premium discount depends on multiple factors including your insurance carrier’s policies, your home’s location and value, the roofing materials you select, and your roof’s age before replacement. Impact-resistant materials and proper documentation can increase savings substantially.
Beyond direct premium reductions, new roofs eliminate age-related surcharges, prevent coverage restrictions, and ensure you maintain full replacement cost coverage rather than depreciated actual cash value reimbursement. These factors often matter more financially than the percentage discount alone.
How Insurance Companies Evaluate Your Roof
Insurance carriers assess roofs systematically when underwriting policies and setting premiums.
Understanding their evaluation process helps you appreciate why new roofs command lower rates and what factors your insurer considers most important.
Age Is the Primary Factor
Roof age determines your baseline insurance rates more than any other roofing-related factor. Insurance companies use age thresholds that trigger premium increases, coverage restrictions, or policy non-renewal.
Most Long Island carriers impose surcharges or restrictions once roofs reach 15-20 years old. At 20-25 years, expect significant premium increases—often 25-50% over standard rates. Beyond 25 years, many carriers refuse to write new policies or cancel existing coverage entirely.
Other factors, such as roof shape, materials, and local risk, also play a role in how your insurer sets rates.
Material Type and Quality
Insurance companies differentiate between roofing materials based on durability, weather resistance, and expected lifespan. Premium architectural shingles command better rates than basic three-tab shingles.
Impact-resistant shingles rated Class 4 by UL 2218 testing qualify for substantial discounts with most carriers. Metal roofing typically receives favorable treatment due to longevity and weather resistance. Budget materials increase premiums due to higher claim frequency.
Condition and Maintenance History
Visible damage, missing shingles, or obvious deferred maintenance increase premiums or trigger coverage denials. Insurance companies conduct roof inspections before writing policies on older homes or when homeowners switch carriers.
Well-maintained roofs with documented professional service receive better rates than neglected roofs of the same age. Regular maintenance records demonstrate responsible homeownership that insurance companies reward with lower premiums.
Your deductible amount can also impact your insurance costs, especially if you have a higher deductible for wind or hail damage.
Location and Weather Exposure
Long Island’s coastal location means insurance companies factor in hurricane exposure, nor’easter frequency, and salt air corrosion. Nassau and Suffolk County homes face higher baseline rates than inland areas.
Proximity to water, wind zone ratings, and local claim history all affect premiums. A new roof doesn’t change your location, but it demonstrates that your home can better withstand regional weather challenges.
FINANCE YOUR HOME IMPROVEMENT PROJECT TODAY
0% Financing, Quick and Easy Approval
With nearly four decades serving homeowners under our belt, we know what’s needed to make your roofing project a success.
When you work with County Roofing, you get only the best. As little as 0% interest on approval for 5 years, quick approval, easy pay, and all backed by the best guarantees in the industry.
Premium Reductions from New Roofs
The financial benefits of new roofs extend beyond obvious premium percentage discounts.
Understanding all the ways new roofs affect insurance costs reveals the full financial picture and helps you calculate actual savings.
Direct Premium Discounts
Most insurance carriers offer 10-25% premium reductions for new roofs, with exact discounts varying by company policy. Insurers offer these discounts to encourage homeowners to maintain their properties. State Farm, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, and other major carriers serving Long Island all provide new roof discounts.
The discount typically remains in effect for 5-10 years after installation, then phases out gradually as your roof ages. Some carriers maintain partial discounts for 15+ years if roofs remain in excellent condition.
Elimination of Age Surcharges
If your current roof is 15-20+ years old, you’re likely paying substantial age-related surcharges—often 25-50% above standard premiums. Replacing your roof eliminates these penalties immediately.
For a policy with $3,000 annual premiums and a 30% age surcharge, you’re paying an extra $900 annually. A new roof eliminates this $900 surcharge while potentially adding a 15% new roof discount. Your effective savings exceed 40% of the surcharged premium.
Improved Coverage Terms
Many insurance policies restrict coverage on older roofs to actual cash value (ACV) rather than replacement cost value (RCV). ACV factors in depreciation, meaning a 20-year-old roof might receive only 20-30% of replacement cost if damaged.
New roofs qualify for full replacement cost coverage. If your roof suffers storm damage, insurance pays to replace it entirely rather than providing a depreciated check that covers a fraction of actual replacement costs. This coverage improvement has tremendous financial value.
Higher Coverage Limits Available
Some insurance carriers restrict maximum coverage amounts on homes with aging roofs. They limit total policy values because older roofs increase claim likelihood and severity.
New roofs allow you to increase coverage limits to appropriate levels for your home’s value. This flexibility ensures adequate protection without paying premium surcharges for insufficient coverage.
Making these upgrades can help you save money by qualifying for a lower premium.
Impact-Resistant Shingles: Extra Savings
Impact-resistant shingles provide additional insurance discounts beyond standard new roof reductions.
These specialized shingles undergo rigorous testing and deliver both superior protection and meaningful premium savings.
What Qualifies as Impact-Resistant
Impact-resistant shingles meet UL 2218 Class 4 impact resistance standards—the highest rating available. These shingles withstand impacts from 2-inch steel balls dropped from 20 feet without cracking or tearing.
Most premium architectural shingles from manufacturers like GAF, CertainTeed, and Owens Corning offer Class 4 impact-resistant options. The cost premium over standard shingles typically runs 10-15%, but insurance savings often exceed this additional investment within 3-5 years.
Insurance Discount Amounts
Impact-resistant shingle discounts vary by carrier but typically range from 15-30% beyond standard new roof discounts. Some Long Island carriers offer combined discounts approaching 35-40% for new impact-resistant roofs.
USAA, State Farm, Allstate, and Liberty Mutual all provide impact-resistant shingle discounts. Specific discount amounts vary by state, location, and individual policy terms, so check with your carrier about available savings.
Long-Term Value Proposition
Beyond insurance savings, impact-resistant shingles reduce damage from hail storms and falling branches—common Long Island weather events. They also help protect against wind damage, which can be a major concern in coastal areas. Fewer claims mean stable premiums over time and better relationships with your insurance carrier.
The combination of upfront insurance discounts, reduced future claim likelihood, and superior durability makes impact-resistant shingles excellent investments for Long Island homeowners concerned about both protection and cost management.
Documentation Requirements
Insurance companies require proof that your shingles meet Class 4 standards. County Roofing Systems provides all necessary documentation including manufacturer certifications, installation receipts showing impact-resistant materials, and warranty papers confirming Class 4 ratings.
This documentation must be submitted to your insurance carrier to receive discounts. Without proper paperwork, you won’t receive savings even if you’ve installed qualifying materials.
In addition to impact-resistant shingles, other mitigation measures like storm shutters may also qualify for insurance discounts, depending on what your insurer recommends.
Age-Based Insurance Penalties You’re Avoiding
Understanding what happens as roofs age helps you appreciate the financial urgency of timely replacement.
The penalties for old roofs extend far beyond simple premium increases and can dramatically affect your financial protection.
The 15-Year Threshold
Most insurance carriers begin imposing restrictions once roofs reach 15 years old. Initial penalties may seem minor—perhaps 5-10% premium increases or requirements for professional roof inspections.
These early restrictions signal that your roof has entered the period where insurance companies expect increased claim frequency. Addressing replacement proactively at this stage prevents more severe penalties later.
Location and Weather Exposure
If you live in a high risk area for hurricanes, windstorms, or other natural disasters, insurance penalties for old roofs may be even more severe. Homeowners in these regions often face higher premiums, limited private insurance options, or may need to rely on government-backed insurance programs.
The 20-Year Cliff
At 20 years, insurance penalties accelerate dramatically. Expect premium surcharges of 25-50% above standard rates, mandatory roof inspections before policy renewal, coverage restrictions to actual cash value only, or requirements for complete roof replacement as a condition of policy renewal.
Some carriers simply refuse to renew policies on homes with 20+ year old roofs. You’ll need to find new insurance, which becomes difficult and expensive when your roof age eliminates many carrier options.
The 25-Year Wall
Beyond 25 years, most insurance carriers won’t write new policies regardless of condition. Existing policyholders may maintain coverage temporarily, but expect non-renewal notices and difficulty finding replacement insurance.
The few carriers willing to insure homes with 25+ year old roofs charge premium rates that often exceed $5,000-$8,000 annually for coverage that costs $2,000-$3,000 with newer roofs. These extreme premiums make roof replacement financially imperative.
Actual Cash Value vs. Replacement Cost
The shift from replacement cost to actual cash value coverage represents the most financially devastating age-related penalty. ACV factors in depreciation, paying only the depreciated value of your damaged roof.
A 20-year-old roof might receive $5,000-$8,000 in ACV coverage for damage that costs $18,000-$25,000 to repair properly. You’re responsible for the $13,000-$17,000 difference—far exceeding any savings from delaying replacement. These changes can impact your entire homeowners policy, not just the roof coverage, affecting deductibles, coverage limits, and overall protection for your home.
Documentation: The Key to Securing Discounts
Proper documentation determines whether you receive insurance discounts and ensures smooth claim processing when damage occurs.
Insurance companies require specific paperwork proving your new roof qualifies for premium reductions.
Essential Documentation to Maintain
Keep detailed records of your roof replacement including complete installation contract showing materials used, final invoice with payment documentation, manufacturer warranty certificates, contractor license and insurance verification, and photographs of completed installation. Make sure your policy documents are updated whenever you make changes to your roof or coverage to ensure your insurance reflects the latest improvements.
County Roofing Systems provides comprehensive documentation packages including all necessary paperwork organized for insurance submission. We understand exactly what carriers require and ensure you receive everything needed.
Submitting Documentation to Insurance
Contact your insurance agent or carrier immediately after roof replacement. Insurance agents can help you understand which documents are needed and how to request discounts. Submit all documentation and request the new roof discount explicitly—don’t assume it applies automatically.
Many homeowners lose thousands in savings by failing to notify insurers or not requesting discounts proactively. Insurance companies rarely offer discounts without requests and proper documentation.
Certificate of Completion
Some insurance carriers require certificates of completion from licensed contractors. These certificates verify that work meets code requirements and was performed by qualified professionals.
If you have extra coverage for high-value items, review and update these endorsements after a major home improvement like a new roof to ensure your protection matches your current needs.
County Roofing Systems provides certificates of completion for all installations. This documentation proves professional installation and satisfies insurance carrier requirements.
Inspection Reports
Several insurance companies conduct their own roof inspections after replacement to verify condition and materials. Schedule these promptly to activate discounts without delay.
Our installations pass insurance inspections consistently because we follow manufacturer specifications exactly and use only quality materials. We’ll coordinate with your insurance company to facilitate inspection scheduling.
How Much You’ll Actually Save
Calculating real savings requires considering all financial factors—direct discounts, eliminated surcharges, improved coverage, and long-term cost avoidance.
Let’s examine realistic scenarios for Long Island homeowners at different premium levels. Choosing a higher deductible can lower your premiums, but make sure you can afford the out-of-pocket cost if you need to file a claim.
Scenario 1: $2,000 Annual Premium
Current situation with 20-year-old roof: $2,000 base premium + 30% age surcharge = $2,600 annually.
After new roof replacement: $2,000 base premium – 15% new roof discount = $1,700 annually.
Annual savings: $900 ($2,600 – $1,700). Over 25 years: $22,500 in insurance savings.
Scenario 2: $3,500 Annual Premium
Current situation with 18-year-old roof: $3,500 base premium + 25% age surcharge = $4,375 annually.
After new impact-resistant roof: $3,500 base premium – 25% combined discount = $2,625 annually.
Annual savings: $1,750 ($4,375 – $2,625). Over 25 years: $43,750 in insurance savings.
Scenario 3: $5,000 Annual Premium
Current situation with 22-year-old roof: $5,000 base premium + 40% age surcharge = $7,000 annually (if coverage available).
After new impact-resistant roof: $5,000 base premium – 20% new roof discount = $4,000 annually.
Annual savings: $3,000 ($7,000 – $4,000). Over 25 years: $75,000 in insurance savings.
These calculations don’t account for improved coverage quality—the shift from actual cash value to replacement cost coverage has tremendous value that’s difficult to quantify precisely but matters enormously if insurance claims occur. The amount paid out in the event of a claim depends on your coverage type.
Fewer insurance claims due to a new roof can also help keep your premiums lower over time.
THE BEST GUARANTEE IN THE INDUSTRY
50-Year Material, 25-Year Labor Guarantee
We’ve met the toughest requirements in the residential roofing industry- and we use only the best materials.
That’s why we stand behind our work with the best guarantee in the industry– including warranties only 2% of roofing companies can offer.
Your house deserves the best roofing warranty on the market. Give us a call today and get a brand new roof with a 50-year material, 25-year labor warranty from the best roofing contractor in Long Island and New York.
Timing Your Replacement for Maximum Benefit
Strategic timing of roof replacement maximizes both insurance savings and overall financial benefits.
Understanding optimal replacement timing helps you plan effectively and capture maximum value from your investment as a homeowner.
Don’t Wait for Policy Renewal
Replace your roof as soon as feasible rather than waiting for insurance renewal dates. You can request premium adjustments mid-term after providing documentation to your carrier.
Many carriers prorate refunds for the remaining policy term once you submit new roof documentation. Waiting costs you money through continued age surcharges and coverage restrictions.
Before Age Thresholds
If your roof approaches 15, 20, or 25 years old, replace it before crossing these thresholds. Insurance penalties increase dramatically at these ages.
A 19-year-old roof might face minor surcharges, while a 20-year-old roof triggers substantial penalties. The one-year difference matters significantly for insurance purposes.
After Major Rate Increases
If you receive notice of substantial premium increases due to roof age, replacement becomes financially urgent. The insurance savings from new roofs often pay back replacement costs faster than any other home improvement. Like other home improvements, a new roof can have a significant impact on your insurance costs.
When age surcharges reach 25-40%, your insurance savings over 10 years can approach $10,000-$30,000—substantial return on your roofing investment.
Consider Market Conditions
Material costs fluctuate based on market conditions. If roofing costs are temporarily elevated, balance this against insurance savings you’re losing monthly through age surcharges.
If you’ve made other major purchases or upgrades, review your coverage to ensure everything is protected. Sometimes paying slightly more for replacement now saves more through insurance reductions than waiting for hypothetical material cost decreases that may never materialize.
Working with Your Insurance Company
Successful insurance discount navigation requires understanding carrier procedures and maintaining proper communication.
These strategies ensure you receive all available savings without complications.
Contact Your Agent Early
Inform your insurance agent when planning roof replacement. Ask specifically about available discounts, required documentation, inspection procedures, and timing for premium adjustments.
Some agents provide helpful guidance about maximizing discounts through material selections or installation timing. Others may be unaware of all available discounts—research your insurer’s policies independently.
Request Discounts Explicitly
Never assume discounts apply automatically. Insurance companies rarely reduce premiums without explicit requests and proper documentation.
After replacement, submit all documentation and request new roof discounts in writing. Follow up to confirm premium adjustments appear on your next bill.
Appeal Denied Discounts
If your carrier denies new roof discounts despite qualifying materials and documentation, appeal the decision. Provide additional documentation, reference carrier policy guidelines, and escalate to supervisors if necessary.
County Roofing Systems can provide additional documentation supporting your discount eligibility if carriers request more information.
Shop Competing Carriers
Once you’ve replaced your roof, obtain quotes from multiple insurance carriers. Comparing rates and coverage from different companies is essential to find the best deal. Some companies offer better new roof discounts than others, and shopping can reveal substantial savings opportunities.
If you have multiple policies, such as home and auto policies, consider bundling them with the same company to receive additional discounts.
A new roof will make you an attractive customer. Use this advantage to secure the best possible rates and coverage terms.
Get started on your new roof today and let County Roofing Systems give you a roof that not only increases your home’s value and energy efficiency, but helps you save on insurance costs.
Fill out the form below or give us a call today at (888) 366-6619:
Beyond Insurance: Other Financial Benefits
While insurance savings provide significant value, new roofs deliver additional financial benefits that compound your return on investment.
Understanding the complete financial picture helps justify replacement decisions.
Increased Home Value
New roofs increase home values by $10,000-$25,000 on Long Island depending on home price and roof quality. This appreciation partially or fully offsets replacement costs when you eventually sell.
Real estate appraisers factor roof condition into valuations. New roofs mean higher appraised values, better buyer interest, and stronger negotiating positions. Adding security systems or a security system can further increase your home’s value and may qualify for additional insurance discounts, as home security improvements are highly valued by buyers and insurers alike.
Energy Cost Savings
Modern roofing materials with proper ventilation reduce energy costs by 15-25% compared to aging, poorly ventilated roofs. On Long Island where energy costs are high, this saves $300-$800 annually.
Over 25 years, energy savings can approach $7,500-$20,000—substantial return beyond insurance reductions.
Avoided Emergency Repairs
Old roofs require increasingly frequent emergency repairs—often $800-$2,500 per incident. New roofs eliminate these costs for 15-20+ years.
Avoiding just 2-3 emergency repairs saves $2,000-$7,500 while eliminating stress and disruption from unexpected roof failures.
Prevented Interior Damage
Roof leaks cause interior damage—destroyed ceilings, damaged flooring, ruined belongings, and mold growth requiring expensive remediation. New roofs prevent these costs entirely and help prevent water damage, which is a common and costly insurance claim.
A single significant leak can cause $5,000-$15,000 in interior damage. Prevention provides enormous value that’s difficult to quantify but very real.
The financial benefits of a new roof extend well beyond insurance savings. Improving home security is another way to enhance your home’s protection and potentially save on insurance. Home security improvements, such as installing a security system, can also help lower your insurance costs.
Take Action Today
Your aging roof costs you money every month through excessive insurance premiums, age surcharges, and coverage restrictions.
A new roof from County Roofing Systems not only protects your Long Island home with superior weather resistance and modern materials—it puts hundreds or thousands of dollars back in your pocket annually through reduced insurance costs.
The financial benefits extend far beyond premium discounts. You’re eliminating age surcharges that can exceed 40% of your base premium, restoring full replacement cost coverage that protects your financial interests during claims, and qualifying for impact-resistant shingle discounts that provide additional savings.
Add in increased home value, reduced energy costs, and eliminated emergency repair expenses, and roof replacement becomes one of the smartest financial decisions you can make.
Over your new roof’s 25-30 year lifespan, insurance savings alone can approach $15,000-$50,000 depending on your current premiums and roof age.
Combined with other financial benefits, your new roof investment pays substantial returns while providing the peace of mind that comes from superior protection against Long Island’s challenging coastal weather.
County Roofing Systems has protected Long Island homes for over 35 years with quality workmanship, premium materials, and honest service.
We provide complete documentation ensuring you receive all available insurance discounts, install impact-resistant materials that maximize savings, and stand behind every installation with industry-leading warranties. Don’t let another month pass paying excessive insurance premiums for inadequate roof protection.
Ready to lower your insurance costs while upgrading your home’s protection and appearance? Call County Roofing Systems at (888) 366-6619 for a free roof inspection and insurance savings consultation.
Let’s discuss how a new roof can reduce your premiums, improve your coverage, and deliver lasting value for your Long Island home. Your insurance savings start the moment your new roof is installed—contact us today!
- First Approvals
- 0% financing
- No income check
- Up to 15 years
- Monthly payments as low as $149
Call today or contact us below for a FREE roofing estimate:
Frequently Asked Questions
How quickly do insurance discounts take effect?
Discounts typically apply within 30-60 days after submitting documentation to your carrier. Some companies adjust premiums mid-term with prorated refunds; others apply discounts at next renewal. Contact your agent to understand your carrier’s specific timeline.
Do all insurance companies offer new roof discounts?
Most major carriers provide new roof discounts, but amounts and qualification requirements vary. State Farm, Allstate, Liberty Mutual, USAA, Travelers, and other major Long Island carriers all offer some form of new roof premium reduction. Verify specific discounts with your carrier.
Will insurance cover my new roof if damaged immediately after installation?
Yes, new roofs receive full coverage under homeowners policies. Replacement cost coverage applies from installation day forward. Proper documentation from professional installation ensures smooth claim processing if unlikely immediate damage occurs.
Can I get discounts for partial roof replacement?
Most carriers require complete roof replacement for discounts—partial replacements or repairs typically don’t qualify. The entire roof must be new to meet carrier requirements for premium reductions.
How long do new roof discounts last?
Discounts typically remain in effect for 5-10 years, then phase out gradually. Some carriers maintain partial discounts for 15+ years if roofs remain in excellent condition. Check your carrier’s specific policy terms.
What if I installed my roof myself?
DIY installations rarely qualify for insurance discounts. Carriers require professional installation by licensed contractors with proper documentation, warranties, and insurance coverage. DIY work also creates claim denial risks if installation quality is questioned.
What is a comprehensive loss underwriting exchange (CLUE) report and how does it affect insurance coverage and premiums?
A comprehensive loss underwriting exchange (CLUE) report is a record of insurance claims made on a property over the past several years. Insurers use the CLUE report to assess risk, which can impact your home insurance coverage options and homeowners insurance costs. A history of frequent or severe claims may lead to higher premiums or limited coverage.
How can a CLUE report help you understand a property's claims history before buying or insuring a home?
A CLUE report provides a detailed claims history for a property, helping buyers and homeowners identify past issues such as water damage, fire, or roof problems. Reviewing the CLUE report before purchasing or insuring a home can reveal potential risks and help you anticipate how these might affect your insurance premiums.
